Canada’s Sports System Declared “Broken” in Urgent Reform Report

A new report from the Future of Sport in Canada Commission highlights significant issues within the nation’s sports system, declaring it “broken” and in urgent need of reform. Released on October 12, 2023, the preliminary findings reveal systemic abuse and maltreatment of athletes, calling for immediate action from the federal government to enhance protections.

Commissioner Lise Maisonneuve, a former chief justice of the Ontario Court of Justice, stated during a press conference in Ottawa that the commission’s investigation uncovered “deeply ingrained” problems, including a culture of silence surrounding abuse, underfunding, and a lack of diversity in sports. The commission conducted extensive outreach, engaging with over 825 individuals and collecting more than 1,000 written submissions and survey responses.

The report details a range of serious allegations, including physical punishment, sexual assault, and neglect of medical care for injured athletes. Maisonneuve emphasized that these issues contribute to a culture where conflicts of interest and favoritism thrive. “As many have told us, it is broken,” she said, highlighting the urgent need for change.

Recommendations for Systemic Change

In response to the findings, the report outlines 71 recommendations aimed at overhauling the existing framework. A key proposal is the establishment of an independent body responsible for the oversight, administration, coordination, and strategic leadership of sports and physical activity in Canada. This entity could take the form of a Crown corporation or a not-for-profit organization created through federal legislation.

The commission noted that several other countries, including the United Kingdom, Australia, and New Zealand, have implemented similar bodies to promote safe sport environments. Currently, the Canadian Centre for Ethics in Sport (CCES) only investigates abuse claims linked to national federally funded programs, leaving lower levels of sport to navigate their own systems. In the first quarter of 2023, only 11 out of 111 reports received by the CCES were deemed admissible, underscoring the limitations of the existing framework.

To address these jurisdictional challenges, the commission recommends that the federal government collaborate with provincial and territorial authorities to create a national safe sport authority. This body would ensure consistent administration of safe sport legislation across the country. “We can have a uniform, centralized system in Canada to deal with complaints,” Maisonneuve stated, emphasizing the need for transparency and clarity in the complaint process.

Calls to Action for Transformative Change

The report also urges the government to mandate background screening requirements for sports organizations receiving federal funding. These measures aim to prevent potential abuse and create safer environments for athletes of all ages and backgrounds.

Athletes and witnesses have long called for reforms, sharing their experiences of abuse, harassment, and discrimination. Maisonneuve noted the need for “transformative and profound” change, emphasizing that this moment presents a unique opportunity for the Canadian sports system. “It’s time for Canada to shine on the podium, but also across this nation in hockey arenas, soccer fields, gymnastics clubs, and pickleball courts,” she said.

The findings and recommendations from the Future of Sport in Canada Commission illustrate the urgent need for a comprehensive review and reform of the sports system. If implemented, these changes could pave the way for a more inclusive, equitable, and safe sporting environment for all Canadian athletes.