Assessing Four Fantasy Quarterbacks: Trade, Pick Up, or Hold?

As the NFL season progresses, fantasy football managers are faced with crucial decisions regarding their rosters. Recent performances by four veteran quarterbacks—Matthew Stafford, Sam Darnold, Jared Goff, and Joe Flacco—offer significant insights into their potential value for the remainder of the season. Each quarterback presents unique opportunities and challenges, impacting league strategies across various formats.

Matthew Stafford: Trade for Optimal Performance

Matthew Stafford of the Los Angeles Rams is currently enjoying a remarkable streak, making him a prime target for fantasy trades. Over his last two games, Stafford has thrown nine touchdowns, achieving multiple touchdown passes in six of his past seven games. With just two interceptions this season, he is averaging an impressive 23.3 fantasy points over the last five weeks.

During this span, he has thrown 16 touchdowns, 13 of which were from within the 20-yard line. This indicates that when the Rams enter scoring territory, the offense revolves around Stafford and his ability to execute plays. The Rams have already completed their bye week, and their upcoming schedule features teams that rank outside the top 10 against quarterbacks, including matchups against San Francisco, Seattle, Tampa Bay, and Carolina. With elite receiving options like Puka Nacua and Davante Adams at his disposal, trading for Stafford could significantly bolster fantasy lineups heading into the playoffs.

Sam Darnold: A Valuable Addition

In contrast, Sam Darnold of the Seattle Seahawks presents a compelling case for pickup. Available in over 50% of ESPN leagues, Darnold recently delivered a standout performance against Washington, scoring 27.2 points with a completion rate of 87.5%, amassing 330 passing yards and four touchdowns. Despite a less impressive outing against Houston, Darnold has consistently scored 20 or more points in three of his last four games.

His fit within the Seahawks’ offensive system under coordinator Klint Kubiak has been seamless, characterized by well-structured throws and efficient playmaking. Darnold’s ability to connect with top target Jaxon Smith-Njigba enhances his value, as Smith-Njigba’s performance has proven consistent. Although Darnold’s upcoming matchups against Arizona, Los Angeles, Tennessee, and Minnesota may pose challenges, he offers a solid chance for upside, particularly for those in 12-team leagues seeking a quarterback boost.

Jared Goff: Hold for Stability

The situation with Jared Goff of the Detroit Lions is more nuanced. While Goff has showcased his potential by throwing multiple touchdowns in four of his last five games, he has only managed two performances exceeding 20 points this season, coupled with a lack of rushing upside. This inconsistency leads to a conservative approach; he remains a reliable QB2 but may not be the best candidate for aggressive trade moves.

Goff’s upcoming Week 10 matchup against the Commanders presents a favorable opportunity. Additionally, his performance in the first week of the fantasy playoffs against the Cowboys may warrant further consideration. Goff’s balanced offensive role allows him to average around 16.7 points over his past four games. For now, maintaining Goff as a steady option seems prudent in single-quarterback leagues.

Joe Flacco: A Hidden Gem

Finally, Joe Flacco of the Cincinnati Bengals is a sleeper candidate worth considering for deeper league formats. Despite the Bengals being on a bye week, Flacco remains available in over 65% of ESPN leagues. In his four starts, he has averaged 24.9 points, with a notable volume of 43.3 passing attempts per game. This high throw count reflects the Bengals’ struggles in their run game and a defense that often finds itself in negative game situations.

Upcoming matchups against Pittsburgh, New England, Baltimore, and Buffalo will likely necessitate a pass-heavy approach. Flacco’s aggressive mindset and the presence of elite receivers like Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins position him as a valuable asset capable of contributing significantly to fantasy rosters.

In summary, as managers prepare for the crucial stretch of the season, the performances of these quarterbacks will undoubtedly influence decisions. Whether opting to trade for Stafford, pick up Darnold or Flacco, or hold on to Goff, each choice carries implications for fantasy success.