Catholic Sex Abuse Trial in B.C. Delayed by Last-Minute Bankruptcy

UPDATE: A crucial jury trial in a historical Catholic sexual abuse case has been abruptly delayed due to an 11th-hour bankruptcy declaration by the Presentation Brothers of Ireland. The trial was set to begin at B.C. Supreme Court in Vancouver today and was expected to last four weeks, making this development particularly urgent.

Nicholas Harrison, the plaintiff, is suing the Presentation Brothers and two deceased members—Brother Leopold (Dennis O’Mahoney) and Brother Paschal (Vincent James)—for claims of sexual, physical, and psychological abuse he suffered while attending Sacred Heart Elementary School in Prince George from 1973 to 1977. Harrison’s ongoing civil suit, initiated in 2022, had previously included more defendants, but he has since settled with the Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate and the Diocese of Prince George.

The Presentation Brothers filed for bankruptcy less than a week before the trial’s commencement, a move described by Harrison’s attorney, Sandra Kovacs, as “unexpected” and detrimental to her client. In court, Kovacs stated that the organization has declared liabilities of approximately $72,000 against just $1 in total assets, raising serious concerns about the availability of resources for potential recovery.

“This unexpected delay prejudices my client,” Kovacs told Judge Kevin Loo. She emphasized the emotional toll this has taken on Harrison, who has spent 27 years seeking justice. “The plaintiff does not wish for an adjournment—he has been on a journey for justice—but to proceed without knowing available recovery is foolhardy,” she added.

Judge Loo agreed to adjourn the trial, leaving the next steps uncertain. A creditors’ meeting is scheduled for December 2, 2023, which will reveal more about the organization’s financial situation.

Outside the courtroom, Harrison expressed his disappointment. “I’m very much looking forward to having them answer for all of this,” he said, highlighting the emotional weight he carries. “I want them to feel what it’s like to live in fear and shame, as I have for a long time.”

Harrison, who is a professor, actor, author, and playwright, also voiced solidarity with others who have suffered similar fates, stating, “I stand with ghosts of people who left, who chose to leave because it was easier.”

The Presentation Brothers of Ireland, an international Catholic organization focused on education, has not publicly commented on the situation as of this time. Their denial of the abuse allegations remains filed in court documents.

As the legal saga unfolds, the implications of this delay resonate deeply, not just for Harrison but for all affected by the historical abuse cases within the Catholic Church. The ongoing struggle for justice continues to spotlight the urgent need for accountability and transparency within religious organizations.

Stay connected for more updates as this developing story progresses.