Manor Park Residents Oppose Sidewalks Amid City Infrastructure Project

Residents of Manor Park, a community in Ottawa, are voicing strong opposition to the installation of sidewalks as part of an infrastructure project aimed at upgrading aging sewer and water main systems. Many locals, including longtime resident Peter Burpee, have begun displaying “No Sidewalks” signs to express their discontent. Burpee, who has lived in the area for over 40 years, claims the community is largely against the initiative, believing that the existing streets are safe and accessible without sidewalks.

The City of Ottawa is implementing an “integrated road, sewer and watermain rehabilitation” project that includes plans for sidewalks on one side of several streets. Burpee argues that the character of the 75-year-old planned community would be diminished by these changes. He emphasizes that residents can already safely walk on both sides of the streets, where traffic is minimal.

Burpee’s sentiments reflect a broader community concern. The planned installation has sparked discussions about the potential impact on the neighborhood’s aesthetics and existing vegetation. “We don’t need sidewalks. The streets are safe,” he reiterated, highlighting the existing community dynamics.

City’s Perspective on Sidewalk Installation

According to Elizabeth Murphy, program manager of Transportation Engineering Services for the city, sidewalks are an essential part of the city’s Transportation Master Plan, which aims to promote pedestrian safety and equitable mobility. Murphy describes sidewalks as critical infrastructure that connects residents to schools, parks, and public transit, while also supporting the city’s Vision Zero goals for safety.

The proposed design for Manor Park aims to balance pedestrian safety with the preservation of the neighborhood’s character and existing trees. “Sidewalks are a key infrastructure that supports transportation and promotes equitable mobility,” Murphy stated in a recent communication.

While Burbee and many residents oppose the sidewalks, they agree that high-traffic areas, particularly those near schools, require better pedestrian infrastructure. Natalie Belovic, president of the Manor Park Community Association, notes that many residents feel funding for sidewalks could be better allocated to areas where they are genuinely needed, such as near Manor Park Public School on Braemar Street, which currently lacks adequate sidewalks despite being a primary drop-off location.

Community Concerns and Ongoing Discussions

Community discussions have been ongoing, with residents expressing their anxiety about the changes. Belovic points out that the unique charm of Manor Park lies in its “front-yard neighbourhood” feel, where children play in the streets due to low traffic volume. “People are concerned that sidewalks will dramatically change the look and feel of the neighborhood,” she said.

City Councillor Rawlson King supports the inclusion of sidewalks, emphasizing their importance for safety and accessibility. He highlights that the construction project is not solely about upgrading utilities but also about enhancing community infrastructure. King has organized information sessions to address residents’ concerns, aiming to foster a better understanding of the integrated renewal projects.

On the other hand, Eugenie Waters, chair of the Manor Park Community Association’s Environmental Sustainability Committee, raises valid concerns about visibility and safety, particularly during school hours when traffic congestion increases. “I often see parents speeding in front of my house, after they dropped off their child,” she shared, noting the need for safer street designs.

The debate continues to engage various community members, including advocates for pedestrian safety like Nick Grover of Ecology Ottawa. He argues for the necessity of sidewalks as a means to ensure safe passage for all, especially in light of recent accidents involving children. Grover insists that infrastructure improvements should prioritize pedestrian safety and accessibility.

As the city prepares to implement these changes, the next community information session with Councillor King is scheduled for July 30, 2023, at 6 p.m. in the main hall at 1805 Gaspé Ave. This meeting represents an opportunity for residents to voice their concerns and engage in discussions about the future of their neighborhood. The outcome of this project may well influence the character and safety of Manor Park for years to come.