Owners of Emily Carr’s House Seek Rental Exemption for Restoration

The owners of the historic House of Allsorts in Victoria, British Columbia, are requesting an exemption from provincial short-term rental regulations to secure funding for essential restoration work. This lesser-known residence, associated with renowned Canadian artist Emily Carr, is over 112 years old and holds the distinction of being the only privately-owned historic site in the province.

Located in Victoria, the House of Allsorts became a significant part of Carr’s life during her adulthood. Carr, who is celebrated for her contributions to Canadian art, named the building herself, and traces of her presence remain, particularly in the attic where several of her original paintings are located. The original artwork on the attic ceiling, along with some copies displayed elsewhere, reflect Carr’s creative legacy.

Current owner Peter Willis has faced challenges in maintaining the property since it was designated historic shortly after his grandmother purchased it in 1973. While the nearby Emily Carr House is maintained by provincial funds, the responsibility for the upkeep of the House of Allsorts falls solely on Willis.

“I think I can manage the restoration if I can get a short-term rental exemption,” Willis explained. The property has long-term tenants on the bottom floor, and two suites on the second level are available for a minimum stay of 90 days. However, since Willis does not reside in the house, he is barred from listing it on the short-term rental market.

Willis estimates that he would require approximately $800,000 for a complete restoration of the historic building. He believes that granting the exemption aligns with the province’s moral and ethical obligations to support the preservation of its cultural heritage.

The request is currently under review by the Attorney General’s legal services branch, which has not yet provided a response to inquiries from CHEK News regarding the matter. As discussions continue, the future of the House of Allsorts hangs in the balance, with its historical significance and potential restoration efforts at stake.