Saanich Residents Critique New Developments for Lack of Creativity

Concerns have emerged over the recent developments in Saanich, with residents expressing dissatisfaction regarding the design and height of new buildings. In a letter published in the Saanich News on October 22, 2023, resident Lee Thiessen articulated a growing frustration with the current council’s approach to urban development, particularly the trend towards constructing high-rise buildings in residential areas.

Critics argue that the council’s push for buildings ranging from 10 to 15 storeys threatens the character of Saanich’s traditionally leafy neighbourhoods. Thiessen described these new structures as “mind-numbingly dull buildings containing overpriced tiny spaces designed to churn through transient tenancies.” This sentiment resonates with many residents who question whether such environments are suitable for families.

Specific locations, such as the blocks at Mackenzie and Shelbourne, have been highlighted as examples of uninspired architectural choices. Residents are concerned that these developments resemble “Lego-block construction,” lacking creativity and consideration for community aesthetics.

Moreover, the proposed public spaces, such as the “plaza” associated with these developments, have drawn skepticism. Residents fear these areas may mimic the poorly planned parking lot at Tuscany Village, which many consider a failure in urban design. Jan Cook, another Saanich resident, expressed her disappointment with the current trend, stating that in the rush to address housing demands, there is a notable absence of charm and character in these projects.

The ongoing debate reflects a broader tension between the need for increased housing and the desire for thoughtful, community-oriented design. Many residents believe that maintaining the unique character of Saanich should be a priority, suggesting that height restrictions similar to those at Tuscany Village could foster a more harmonious development approach.

As discussions continue, it remains to be seen how the Saanich Council will balance the pressing need for housing with the community’s desire for aesthetically pleasing and functional living spaces. The outcome of this dialogue will likely shape the future of Saanich and its residential landscape.