Manitoba Tories Advocate for Retention of Royal Anthem in Schools

In a move reflecting ongoing political tensions, the Manitoba Progressive Conservatives have voiced their opposition to a proposed bill that seeks to remove the requirement for schools to optionally sing the royal anthem, God Save the King. The bill, known as Bill 40, passed its second reading in the legislature on March 15, 2024, and is currently set to undergo committee review where public input will be solicited.

With U.S. President Donald Trump making remarks perceived as threatening to Canada’s economy and sovereignty, the Manitoba Tories argue that now is not the moment to eliminate this patriotic observance. The legislation has drawn attention following a recent push to reinstate the anthem in schools within the Mountain View School Division, based in Dauphin.

Political Statements and Community Reaction

Wayne Ewasko, the Progressive Conservative education critic, emphasized the importance of maintaining local autonomy in educational decisions. In a news release, he remarked, “Our amendments will preserve the school divisions’ freedom to make decisions at the local school division level.” Although the singing of the royal anthem has not been enforced for decades, Ewasko believes it should remain an option for schools.

In contrast, Premier Wab Kinew defended the bill, suggesting that it eliminates a redundant regulation that has not been observed for many years. During a news conference, he stated, “This is just red tape. This is just something that nobody has observed for decades, and so we’re removing it from statute.” Kinew reassured that schools still have the freedom to sing the royal anthem if they choose.

“Everyone’s free to wear your monarchist pin and sing ‘God Save the King’ and to gossip about (Royals) Meghan and Harry to your heart’s content,” said Kinew.

Historical Context and Ongoing Traditions

Manitoba’s connection to the monarchy has a long history, dating back over 150 years. Last November, Kinew was awarded the King Charles III Coronation Medal by Gov. Gen. Mary Simon, recognizing his contributions to the province. A month later, he presented King’s Coronation Medals to 27 Manitobans for their significant achievements.

The debate surrounding the royal anthem has sparked questions about Kinew’s commitment to Canadian traditions. Ewasko challenged the Premier’s stance, asking, “Why does Wab Kinew think now is the right time to strip the royal anthem from schools? Does his allegiance, patriotism and respect for the Crown and Canadian traditions only apply when cameras are rolling?”

This ongoing discussion reflects broader sentiments regarding national identity and the role of royal traditions in contemporary Canada. As the legislative process continues, the outcome of Bill 40 will likely influence how future generations engage with these historical symbols.