Blue Jays Face Crucial Decisions Ahead of Playoffs Next Week

UPDATE: The Toronto Blue Jays have officially clinched a playoff spot as of September 21, 2025, but urgent questions loom as they prepare for the postseason. With the playoffs just around the corner, key decisions regarding player rotations and lineups will determine their success.

The pressure is on as the Blue Jays strategize to avoid facing elimination in the best-of-three series. One of the most pressing concerns involves the pitching rotation. Will Trey Yesavage be the team’s #3 pitcher? Speculation is rife, with Kevin Gausman and Shane Bieber expected to lead the charge. Meanwhile, uncertainties surround veteran pitchers like Chris Bassitt and Max Scherzer, particularly if Scherzer underperforms as the season wraps up.

As fans eagerly await answers, the Blue Jays’ playoff roster remains a mystery. Depending on how many starters transition to bullpen roles, crucial decisions will need to be made regarding relievers. Will Scherzer be converted to a reliever if he doesn’t make the rotation? And what about Jose Berrios? These uncertainties leave several relievers anxious about their postseason prospects.

Another major question mark is the status of Anthony Santander. If he recovers in time, how will the team utilize him? His potential return could significantly impact the postseason strategy, making him a game-changer if fit.

Furthermore, the health of Bo Bichette remains critical. If he can return to the lineup, will the Blue Jays risk altering their solid defense, especially with Andres Gimenez performing well at shortstop? His comeback could trigger a chain reaction affecting multiple players.

With so much at stake, several hitters, including Nathan Lukes, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, and Joey Loperfido, face the risk of being left out of the playoff roster. The decision-making process will be complex, reflecting the team’s intentions and strategies moving forward.

Fans are on the edge of their seats as the Blue Jays gear up for their playoff run, set to commence next week. The team has until then to finalize their roster and ensure they are ready to make a deep postseason push.

Stay tuned as we continue to cover these developing stories and bring you the latest updates from the Blue Jays camp. Will they rise to the challenge? The clock is ticking, and every decision counts.