Sault Ste. Marie Weighs Controversial Arms Maker Proposal

UPDATE: The Sault Ste. Marie City Council has just approved a resolution to explore the feasibility of attracting a defense or munitions manufacturing facility to the area, despite significant ethical concerns raised by community members. The vote, which passed with a majority, will allow city staff to investigate potential opportunities for bringing an arms maker to the city.

In a poll conducted by SooToday last week, fewer than 10 percent of respondents opposed the initiative, yet strong sentiments emerged during the council meeting. Ward 3 Councillor Angela Caputo, who voted against the resolution alongside Councillors Lisa Vezeau-Allen and Luke Dufour, expressed deep concerns about the implications of such a business. “It has become way too simple and acceptable to kill other people,” Caputo declared, emphasizing the moral dilemmas associated with the arms trade.

The resolution was spearheaded by Councillors Corey Gardi and Ron Zagordo, who argued that attracting a munitions facility could create much-needed jobs and economic stability in the community. Mayor Matthew Shoemaker supported the motion, stating, “If we can capitalize on some of that money flowing into our community, we have an obligation to look at whether we are well suited to do that.”

During the meeting, Caputo voiced her frustrations, stating, “At what cost are we willing to sell our city and our integrity?” She called for leaders to prioritize peace over profit, adding, “It’s 2025, and we can and should do better.”

Councillor Vezeau-Allen also opposed the resolution, highlighting potential environmental impacts and advocating for cleaner industries that could utilize resources from Algoma Steel. “We don’t know what the environmental impact could be on munitions,” she warned, stressing the importance of sustainability.

Dufour echoed these sentiments, recalling concerns about companies that have faced backlash over their military contracts. “When you’re committed to making a certain type of military equipment, you are committing yourself to selling that to whoever’s going to pay you for it,” he cautioned.

Despite opposition, Gardi defended the resolution, acknowledging the presence of concerned citizens at the meeting. He recognized the global context, stating, “All of the NATO countries have decided to increase their defense spend.” Gardi emphasized the need for local industry to adapt to these changes for economic survival.

The decision has ignited a passionate debate within the community, with many residents questioning the ethical implications of entering the arms manufacturing sector. As discussions continue, city officials will begin assessing the potential impact of attracting an arms maker to Sault Ste. Marie.

NEXT STEPS: City staff are expected to conduct research on the feasibility of this proposal in the coming weeks, while community members remain engaged in the ongoing conversation about the future of their city. As the situation develops, residents are urged to stay informed and participate in discussions surrounding this controversial initiative.

This resolution marks a pivotal moment for Sault Ste. Marie, highlighting the delicate balance between economic growth and ethical responsibility. The impact of this decision will resonate in the community for years to come.